When you’re building taxonomies (classification systems) and maintaining them (classes shift and change e.g., in the UK “chavs”, came from another “class” and have morphed into others etc.), there are often unidentifiable classes/groups of people who are difficult to define/classify. It is important to understand that grouping/classifying people isn’t about labelling them, but rather about understanding what motivates certain people to act in a particular way. This has practical applications concerning how we manage potentially aggressive individuals; if we can identify why someone is motivated to use violence, we have an opportunity to address this motivation before the individual feels compelled to act upon it. Violence is always the result of an unmet need whether that “need” is emotional, physical, and/or psychological etc. Understanding this doesn’t mean we have to feel sorry or express empathy for that individual (though in some cases this has a practical application), nor does it mean that this “need” is justified, however if we can understand that the root of a violent act, has an origin, and that origin is the desire to fulfill a need, then we are likely to be more successful in preventing violence than simply looking at an angry person as an angry person.

                This article is an unscientific one e.g., it is anecdotal and doesn’t have any measurable components/variables etc., but it is a starting point, and one of the reasons I write daily; to explore ideas, some of which I discard, some of which I investigate, and some of which may result in being included in a taxonomy etc. One of the things I’ve personally recognized, and I know others have, post COVID-19 pandemic, is that people in general seem more aggressive and angry. Something I’ve noticed concerning aggressive driving and road-rage. Admittedly I live in Massachusetts where this is a known issue/problem, however when you notice an uptick in a locale that already has a high number of incidents, you have to question why. Sometimes art and entertainment expresses ideas better than science and academia which is why – understandably - more people watch Netflix than read scientific journals. I remember a line in a UK TV Show (Sherwood), where an investigating officer describes a town/community as having a “mood” about it. Communities and societies are shaped by events that they share collectively. In this show it was the miner’s strike of the 1980’s, something that I think many people in the UK have consciously forgotten but are still emotionally and psychologically affected by. I also don’t think anyone who experienced 9/11 isn’t still affected by it, and for that matter the COVID-19 pandemic. As a small business, I’m only now starting to get over the financial hit it took, and dealing with practical issues is far easier and quicker than dealing with the deeper ramifications of something.

                I have written before about a type of violent offender who is referred to/classified as an “Injustice Collector”. These are individuals who start to develop a world view, where everyone is out to get them, because they have interpreted past events as contests where everything has been set up to make them lose. Because of this they see every possible/potential future event as one where they’ll be made to be the “sucker” etc. All of this has been based on an interpretation of personal experiences. However, this doesn’t explain or describe the general anger and injustice that seems to affect a certain population in our society i.e., individuals who have not directly been the victims of an identifiable/definable injustice but react as if they have. Importantly, this doesn’t discount what they believe and feel, because that is real. Neither should it be patronized or ignored. I struggled to identify exactly what this type of anger was, where it came from etc., but a line in an article written by Dr. Gavriel Schneider, articulated it extremely well. Talking about where many societies are now, after the COVID-19 pandemic he said/wrote, “That period taught a dangerous lesson to a segment of our society: that grievance is a legitimate identity, that institutions are adversaries, and that confrontation, whether at a protest, online or in a supermarket aisle, is how you get heard." The part that stood out for me was “grievance is a legitimate identity”.

                I believe Viktor Frankl, when he said that man’s search, is a search for meaning. To the age-old philosophical question about what separates “man” from animals, my simple answer would be “meaning”. A dog doesn’t question who they are, and they don’t search for any existential meaning in/for their lives. They may question whether they are loved, but they won’t question what love is etc. Humans, however, question everything, which is one of the reasons we are the masters of self-deception and lie to ourselves all the time i.e., we don’t have the answers for our own meaning, and so we engage in self-deception to avoid having to face a void and deal with it. I am coming to the conclusion that just as there are “Injustice Collectors” there are “Grievance Identifiers”, i.e., individuals who have no personal/individual reason/experience to feel/perceive an injustice but do so existentially. It is not that Injustice Collectors don’t believe that society and everyone is against them like Grievance Identifiers, but rather their world view has been organically developed and built up over a history of individual experience, whereas a Grievance Identifier is recognizing and associating with a collective experience/viewpoint that they haven’t experienced or witnessed firsthand.

                I used to explain such beliefs, actions and behaviors as part of “moral panics” and the creation of “folk devils” etc. However, these ideas expressed events as moments in time rather than an attitude/belief system that was fixed and held over time. It may be that Grievance Identifiers are more susceptible to moral panics; however the idea of a moral panic fixes the panic as something external/media created rather than coming from a particular world view etc. A view that Ulrich Beck introduced (and was later expanded upon by Anthony Giddens), which stated that modern industrial society has shifted its primary social and political focus from distributing wealth and material goods to managing and mitigating self-produced risks and hazards.